Yesterday veterans joined together in a ceremony to express our opposition to a South Vietnamese monument being placed in a memorial dedicated to veterans who served in the United States military. The memorial is dedicated to the United States Army, United States Marine Corp, United States Navy, United States Air Force, United States Coast Guard and the United States Merchant Marine.
The saddest part of this story is veterans were ignored by two of three television stations in Wichita and the Wichita Eagle. Coverage was handled by an independent examiner, KSN and yours truly. KSN’s coverage of the ceremony was misleading in the opening of the video.
Debate continues over Vietnamese memorial
WICHITA, Kansas (KSN) — An event designed to remember soldiers during the week of Independence Day turned into a rally against a new memorial proposed for the Veterans Memorial Park.
Members of the city’s large Vietnamese community would like to see a monument added to the park honoring soldiers from their homeland who fought side-by-side with U.S. troops against the communists during the Vietnam War.
Many veterans are against the idea. They say the park is for Americans and only Americans.
Veteran John Wilson said the proposal comes from a “misguided, misinformed minority”. Wilson went on to say diminishing the respect for the memorial “is not a bone to throw diversity and so called political correctness.”
Patriot guard co-founder Dennis Scuffham said he had no problem with a memorial honoring the Vietnamese, as long as it’s kept out of the Veterans Memorial Park.
Wichita Mayor Carl Brewer spent his evening at a town hall meeting geared for the city’s Vietnamese community. As a veteran, Brewer said he understood both sides of the issue.
Brewer said the city is meeting with both veterans and Vietnamese leaders hoping to come up with some sort of compromise.
If they can’t, the City Council will vote on the proposal at their July 14th meeting.
Unfortunately some Wichita council members have hijacked the proposed meeting between the Vietnamese community and the Veteran activists.
There were several speakers who discussed what the memorial means to veterans and our opposition to the City of Wichita’s possible decision to place the other monument in our memorial park.
John Wilson, “Duty, Honor, Country”
What is an American Veteran?
Someone before me has answered this already with the simple statement; “A veteran – whether active duty, retired, national guard, or reserve – is someone who, at one point in his or her life, wrote a blank check made payable to The ‘United States of America’, for an amount of ‘up to and including my life.”
America has been a beacon to the rest of the world since our countries inception. She has been a
source of refuge for people fleeing the tyranny of evil throughout the world. The poor, downtrodden and oppressed have flocked to America’s shores searching for a better place to live and a place to raise their families in peace, and when people and countries throughout the world were in distress America has answered their pleas for help by sending its military to fight for them.
America stands guard for the world at a price, and that price is the blood of our sons and daughters, our Veterans. Americas Veterans are men and women who stepped forward because something in them compels them to stand up and fight for their fellow man, men and women to whom “Duty, Honor, Country” are not just words but a way of life.
General Douglas MacArthur, far more eloquent than I am, once said:
“Duty, Honor, Country: Those three hallowed words reverently dictate what you ought to be, what you can be, what you will be. They are your rallying points: to build courage when courage seems to fail; to regain faith when there seems to be little cause for faith; to create hope when hope becomes forlorn.”
McArthur goes on to talk about the American Veteran:
“I do not know the dignity of their birth, but I do know the glory of their death. They died unquestioning, uncomplaining, with faith in their hearts, and on their lips the hope that we would go on to victory. Always, for them: Duty, Honor, Country; always their blood and sweat and tears, as we sought the way and the light and the truth.”
Sometimes when I see the courage and selflessness of our young men and women who willingly go to war in Afghanistan or Iraq to fight against terrorism my eyes tear up in sadness, not only at the bravery and sacrifice of these incredible people who stand guard for us but also because they are doing it instead of me. I am not alone. Most American Veterans feel this way but it is not something that can be easily expressed and we remain silent.
Our duty as Veterans does not end with the termination of our enlistment. Duty compels us to not
only give our support to the active duty men and women who stand guard for us today but to honor the remembrance of those who have fallen before us. It is our duty to remember the sacrifices of the American Veterans who have fought and died in countless battles in foreign lands throughout the world so that we, their mothers, fathers, sons and daughters could be safe.
The remainder of the speech can be read here.
John Scuffman, “Our Mission & Facts”
OUR MISSION is To preserve, honor and protect our Veterans Memorial Park for memorials that honor men and women who have served in the United States Armed Forces.
America owes no debt of gratitude to the South Vietnamese Army. And while, philosophically, we can appreciate and respect what they did for their own country; they did not fight for our freedoms, our country, or our way of life.
The Vietnamese Community claims that the purpose of their memorial is to express their appreciation and gratitude to the American Soldiers who came to fight and die for them in Vietnam.
Even though the Vietnamese Community knows that the majority of Veterans feel an intense disrespect and anger in the insistence that soldiers pledged to a foreign government should be honored in our Veterans Memorial Park, the Vietnamese Community has not withdrawn their demand.
Their disregard for Veteran’s traditions and opinions shows profound disrespect
for the same people who risked their lives for them in South Vietnam.
• The FACTS are as follow and you can follow on your hand out
• The John Stevens Veterans Memorial Park was conceived as a park to
honor Veterans of the United States Armed Forces.
• The only memorials that exist in the Park now are to men and women
who served in the United States Military.
• The Park has limited space and many Americans remain to be
commemorated.
• There is already a Vietnam Memorial in the Park.
• The proposed memorial has wording that honors foreign soldiers who
were pledged to a foreign government
• The Veterans’ objections to the memorial are not related to race or
national origin. The American Armed Forces is the ultimate “multicultural”
organization and our memorials are to Americans of all races,
creeds, and national origins.
• The right to be memorialized in the Veteran’s Memorial Park is earned
by honorable service in the United States Military, and by nothing else.
The remainder of the speech may be read here.
Linda Kirby, “The Sun Is Getting High in the Sky and I Am the Last Speaker of the Day”
Veterans have been ridiculed by our public officials and our media as racist because we oppose a monument to soldiers of a foreign government in Veterans Memorial Park. Because of the frustrated comments of a few, Veterans collectively have been accused of being dangerous.
It is abundantly clear that we have failed to teach the value of patriotism to our community and
failed to impress on a few of our fellow Veterans, and at least one City council member, the imperative of self-control and civility.
One part of Patriotism is love of country. In America, we share a love of country felt by people all over the world. This part of Patriotism is based on our natural love of family, home, community and all things familiar. America has a long history of absorbing new people from foreign lands, and when a new people come to America, they long for what they left behind. It is difficult for these newcomers to feel the same love for a new land that they feel for the land of their birth. Their faces are turned toward remembering the homeland they left.
In America we also celebrate another aspect of Patriotism; this Patriotism is based on the deep rooted
belief that America represents an ideal of democracy, justice and equality for all people that is unparalleled throughout the world. We feel this so deeply and so strongly that we believe it worth the sacrifice of the lives of our youth. We make this sacrifice not only for our American homeland, not only for our love of our families, our homes and our communities, but for the principle that the people of the world are entitled to live in a free and democratic society. It is our Constitution that embodies this ideal and it is the men and women of the American Armed Forces who leave their homes, their families and their communities to uphold and defend with their lives our Constitution against all who would oppose democracy, justice and equality for all people.
The right to be memorialized as a veteran in this park is not gained by polite social nods from a few politically ambitious multi-culturalists. In America, a lump of concrete and metal does not create respect or honor. The American service men and women memorialized in this park earned the right to our respect and honor by their service in the Armed Forces of these United States in defense of the Constitution of our United States. The claim of a right to a memorial for any other reason shows a grave misunderstanding of what these memorials mean and disrespects the sacrifice of our military and their families.
We invite the Vietnamese Community to join the riches of your culture to the multitude of cultures of other people who have come together in America, remember the land of your birth and cherish your distinct language and culture, but we insist that you leave your political and military allegiances and affiliations behind you in the country you lost and left. Join us, as Americans together, in recognizing the service and sacrifice of those men and women of all races, religions, and national origins, who served together in the United States Armed Forces.
Linda Kirby
For more information on this issue visit Kansas Veterans Action Committee (KSVAC).
Please help get this information out to the general public. It is another attack on the veterans community by a biased media and liberal City Council led by Mayor Carl Brewer. This memorial belongs to veterans of the United States Military and that sanctity must be saved for all to share especially those now returning from Iraq and Afghanistan.
I was asked a question by a non-veteran that I failed to answer in this post. My friend asked me why I was so against the Vietnamese monument….here is the answer to that question…any memorial to war dead or veterans who have passed on is sacred land to us and should be treated as such.